Kick-Ass. The title is also the easiest way to describe Mark Millar’s 8-issue comic series that ran from February 2008 to the same month this year, 2010. Though some comic readers may have been a little wary about this title (since it isn’t something a teenager could commonly discuss around adults lest they get a death glare or punished [even when discussing it around my mom I have to call it “that ‘super-hero’ movie with Nicolas Cage {not to be confused with Ghost Rider}]) it is definitely worth the read if you don’t have a problem with copious amounts of profanity and an overall R-rated experience. Kick-Ass is what every teenage comic nerd wishes they could be, a powerless kid who still manages to dress up in a ridiculous costume and beat the crap out of bad guys.
WARNING: From here on out, there will be spoilers. So unless you have already seen/read it, or don’t care that I’m going to be ruining major plot elements, turn back now and come back when you have seen it. I’ll still be here, don’t worry.
How many times have you seen a movie based on a book or comic and thought it was better than the source material? Probably not as many times as you’ve seen a really crappy movie adaptation, and unfortunately Kick-Ass falls into the latter category. Before you open up a flame war saying “oh you suck your opinion is wrong blah, blah, blah” take a step back and realize this is just my opinion, and I’m not holding you at gunpoint to read this.
Sure the Kick-Ass comic was profane, sure it was super-violent, and sure there were some elements that were a little perverse, but that’s what you expect going into a book with such a title. Dave (the main character for those of you who skipped my warning) fantasizes dirty things about one of his teachers, and that fact is only mentioned in passing to further understand the kind of person the story’s protagonist is. The movie takes those few sentences and decides to make a completely needless scene visualizing his fantasy, just for the sake of throwing out all cynicism and jumping into the lake of haplessly juvenile. The movie also could have done without the multiple shots of Dave acting on these fantasies at home, another detail that was only mentioned through internal monologue in the comic.
There are several details of the story that were altered in the movie that are forgivable just for the sake of storytelling ease, but there are also a fair amount of completely unnecessary changes that take the suspense of the comic and chuck it out the window. One of the things that made the character of Big Daddy as awesome as he was, was the fact that he wasn’t actually the ex-supercop he raised his daughter (Hit-Girl, again for those ignoring me earlier) to think he was, he was just a comic book nerd to the extreme that wanted his daughter to live an exciting life. The movie took that twist and completely ignoring it, keeping Big Daddy an ex-cop who was a little off the deep end. Another thing that was changed about Big Daddy was how he died. In the comic it was a grotesquely detailed shot to the back of the head, where in the movie he was burned alive. This wasn’t a horrible change, but it leads to my next big problem with a character.
Hit-Girl is a crazy, ultra-violent ten year old who swears worse than a soldier, everything about her character makes the stomachs of the weak churn. The film version of Kick-Ass keeps most of her character the same, which I appreciated, even though she had an incredibly stupid purple wig in the movie. After realizing that her father has been killed, she brushes it to the side saying “mourn later, kill now.” This first comes across as her being completely hollow and crazy until after the last enemy dies, she turns to Kick-Ass with tears running down her face as she asks, “can I have a hug, my daddy just died.” That single frame was immensely sad while at the same time showing her as a real ten year old girl. The movie threw out the drastic change from violent to sweet in exchange for a more human reaction of instant tears. This doesn’t work in context of her character because she isn’t a normal girl, she grew up wanting not a pony or pretty bows, but assault rifles and butterfly knives.
The last major character screw up is an understandable one, but one that was overdone to the point where it ruined the movie for me. Red Mist had the biggest plot twist in the comic, going from Kick-Ass’s biggest fanboy to pulling a gun to the back of his head and leading to Big Daddy’s death. Being introduced as just another costumed hero that just happens to be doing better than Kick-Ass, there was no real suspicion about any ulterior motives on his part, but the movie version of Red Mist has the word “traitor” painted on his costume with bright yellow ink. Being introduced in the film as the son of the main Mobster (he had that introduction in the comic too, it just wasn’t revealed that HE was Red Mist until the betrayal scene) and basically saying to his father in a scene halfway through the movie “hey dad, I’ll pretend to be a superhero too and trap Kick-Ass for you so you’ll love me and not think I’m a useless piece of crap” ruined all surprise in the third act.
The final big change made was the last scene. This scene took the very last shred of hope that I had in the film and burned it to a crisp. The comic ended with Dave helping Hit-Girl find her mom so she could live a normal life as a normal little girl, but the movie ignores this in favor of inserting a JETPACK WITH GATLING GUNS ON IT to end the final fight, then fly off into the sunset happily ever after. What made them decide to put in a JETPACK WITH GATLING GUNS is beyond me, but it was a horrible choice to replace Hit-Girl gaining a childhood with a GATLING GUN JETPACK. The only part of the final scene I like is that they kept Red Mist saying the final line. Only instead of writing a threatening blog post, he’s talking to himself as he shoots a pistol at the camera, not perfect, but acceptable all the same.
This ends my rant on Kick-Ass, note that this is just a comic nerd critiquing yet another bust of a film adaptation so don’t let me stop you from seeing the movie if you really want to.
“As a great man once said, wait until they get a load of me.” – Red Mist talking about The Joker.